If you’re comparing Angi vs Thumbtack vs HomeAdvisor for remodeling work, start with this: two of the three names are one company on one contract. Angi’s pro agreement is between you and “HomeAdvisor Inc. d/b/a Angi Pro,” so the real comparison is between two sets of terms.
Here are the verdicts on Angi vs Thumbtack for pros, with HomeAdvisor folded in, judged on what each company’s own published terms say.
For small jobs and repairs: Thumbtack’s terms fit better. You set your own lead price, you’re not locked into a term, and competition on each project is capped.
For mid-size remodeling: Thumbtack still has the cleaner terms, but whether either works depends on whether the leads look like the jobs you want.
For full remodels: none of the three is built for it. Angi’s contract never mentions job size at all, and Thumbtack’s per-lead model was designed around smaller, faster jobs.
The test running through all of it is simple. Which company’s terms are built for the size of job you actually sell? Better or worse in general is the wrong question for a remodeler.
What you are actually signing
What’s the difference between Angi and HomeAdvisor for a contractor? On paper, almost none. The >Angi pro agreement is a single contract, between you and HomeAdvisor Inc. doing business as Angi Pro. Angi and HomeAdvisor share one contract, so any comparison that treats them as separate options on terms is comparing a company to itself. Thumbtack publishes its own Terms of Use and its own budget and fee terms, and those are the only genuinely separate set.
The charging models differ. Angi offers a subscription, pay-per-lead, or a bundle of the two. Thumbtack has you set an exact price you’re willing to pay per lead, with a weekly budget that caps total spend. In Thumbtack’s own words, “Your Budget is not a subscription.”
Neither company publishes a per-lead price you can read on a public page before signing up. On both, the number shows up only inside the pro account. So if you’re asking how much Angi charges per lead, the honest answer is that it isn’t published, and you learn it after signing up.
Before you sign with either, ask three questions in writing: how many other contractors receive each lead, what happens to a lead that turns out to be wrong, and how you leave. The answers decide more about your cost than the headline price.
There’s a third model outside this comparison: flat-rate plans that charge a fixed monthly fee with no per-lead billing, the way Houzz Pro works. It’s a different trade-off, and it’s worth weighing separately, especially the flat-rate plan built for design-led kitchen and bath shops.
Google’s Local Services Ads also bill per lead, but under Google’s own published rules, and your reviews and profile live on Google rather than on a marketplace. That’s a different decision again, with its own screening and its own charging rules, and it doesn’t belong in a marketplace comparison.
Angi and HomeAdvisor: one contract, and what it says about a big job
Read the contract clause by clause against a remodeling job, and four things stand out.
You pay whether or not you win. Angi’s annual report to the SEC describes lead revenue as fees paid by pros for consumer matches, “regardless of whether the Pro ultimately provides the requested service.” A lead is billable the moment it’s matched.
No competition cap is published. Leads go to several pros, and the contract doesn’t say how many.
There’s no lead-credit policy in the contract. The only channel is a written billing dispute within 30 days, after which charges are “final and not subject to challenge.” Miss that window and the charge stands. If you stay on Angi, review every invoice inside the 30 days and dispute in writing anything that wasn’t a real homeowner with a real project.
The contract never mentions job size. It never mentions project value, ticket size or average job anywhere in its text. Pricing is tied to the type of service and location, so a $90,000 kitchen and a small repair in one category and town are priced by one set of rules.
Volume matters too. In its third-quarter 2026 results, Angi reported leads down about 18% from a year earlier while revenue per lead rose about 10% (>Angi investor relations). Fewer leads, each costing more, on a contract that doesn’t distinguish a big job from a small one.
Thumbtack: the only one that prices by job size
It ties cost to the job. Thumbtack’s fee pages connect what you pay per lead to the kind of job and set the price per lead with you, which makes it the only one of the three whose pricing responds to job type.
It caps competition. Its quality commitment terms say customers can contact no more than five pros from search results per project within four hours. Those terms carry a December 2022 date but are still in force.
It publishes a refund policy. Thumbtack lists situations that qualify for a refund within 45 days, such as an invalid phone number or a duplicate request. One exclusion matters more than all the rest: if the customer hired a different pro, there’s no refund. Losing the job is a cost you carry, and refunds that are granted usually come back as account credit.
There’s no term to exit. No subscription, no renewal clause, no early-termination fee. You can cancel any time.
But money already in your account stays there. Thumbtack’s terms say all sales and fees are final and non-refundable, and you get no refund when you cancel. Promotional credits disappear too.
What the FTC actually charged, and what it did not settle
The FTC vs HomeAdvisor case is the one most contractors have heard about. On March 11, 2022, the Federal Trade Commission filed an >administrative complaint against HomeAdvisor, Inc., alleging false, misleading or unsubstantiated claims about the quality and source of its leads, and specifically that the company often told service providers its leads turned into jobs at rates much higher than it could substantiate. The complaint described the fee structure in plain terms: an annual membership fee of $287.99 plus a separate fee for each lead, and even the FTC, with its investigative powers, described the per-lead fee only as “a separate fee” without publishing a single price. HomeAdvisor agreed to an order in January 2023 requiring payment of up to $7.2 million, and the Commission approved the >final order 3-0 on April 21, 2023. By November 28, 2023, the FTC had returned more than $3 million to service providers through 110,372 checks. These were allegations resolved by a consent order, and no court made a finding of wrongdoing. What the order addressed was how HomeAdvisor marketed its leads. It did not set a lead price, a credit policy or a competition cap, so the questions a remodeler cares most about were never part of the settlement.
Angi vs Thumbtack vs HomeAdvisor: the verdict by ticket size
Here’s where the verdicts reorder, and that reordering is the point.
Repairs and small jobs. A platform that doesn’t price by job size isn’t obviously wrong here, because most jobs are similar in size. What matters more is how many contractors compete for each lead and what happens when a lead is bad. On both counts, Thumbtack’s published five-pro cap and 45-day refund list beat a contract with no cap and only a 30-day dispute window. If most of your work is small, Thumbtack is also the easier one to test, because you can stop at any time without a fee.
Mid-size remodeling. The question shifts to whether the leads look like the work you want. A bathroom remodeler who wants full gut jobs and keeps receiving vanity swaps is paying for the wrong inventory, whatever the per-lead price. Track ten leads from each source before judging, and compare the jobs they turn into. A lower price per lead means little if most of them are jobs you’d turn down.
Full remodels. Here the verdicts converge, and the honest answer is that none of the three is built for it. A contract with no concept of job size can’t price a $90,000 kitchen differently from a drain call, and a per-lead model designed for quick jobs struggles when the homeowner takes three months to decide. Larger firms usually do better owning the channels that bring this work in, and the real question at this size is when to fund a channel instead of a subscription.
One thing doesn’t change at any size: response speed. On every platform, the contractor who calls back first has the advantage.
The renewal date is the real decision
Don’t renew a marketplace subscription you can’t cancel from the dashboard without reading the cancellation terms first.
Angi’s pro agreement auto-renews. The subscription fee can rise up to 10% each term. Cancellation must come “before” renewal, with no number of days published. It’s handled by phone, with no cancel button in the dashboard. There’s no refund for the current term. And the early-termination fee isn’t published anywhere public. It lives in the onboarding contract you signed when you joined.
If you’re looking for how to get out of an Angi contract without a penalty, the cleanest route the terms allow is not renewing, with notice given in time. Not getting the lead volume you expected doesn’t give you a way out, either. The agreement doesn’t treat underperformance as grounds to cancel early.
Put the renewal date on your calendar at least 60 days ahead, and ask your account manager for the early-termination amount in writing well before then. None of that is unusual for marketplace subscriptions. It does mean the real decision is the renewal date, because that’s the only moment you can leave cleanly. If you’re weighing Angi alternatives or Thumbtack alternatives, other lead companies have their own versions of these terms, and it’s worth comparing the second-tier marketplaces and their minimum terms before you commit to any of them.
Is Angi, Thumbtack, or HomeAdvisor better for a remodeling contractor?
For remodeling-sized jobs, Thumbtack’s published terms fit better than Angi’s. It ties lead cost to the job, caps competition at five pros per project in the first four hours, and has no term to exit. Angi and HomeAdvisor share one contract that never mentions job size and doesn’t publish its early-termination fee.
For full remodels, none of the three is built around job value, and none publishes a per-lead price before you sign up. Whether Angi or Thumbtack is worth it for contractors comes down to fit with your job size, so judge them by their contract terms first and their lead volume second. If you already pay one of them, your own close rate on their leads, tracked for a full quarter, is the only performance number that applies to your business.
Before your next renewal date, find your own onboarding contract, the one with the early-termination fee written into it. That number isn’t on any public page, and it’s the one that decides whether staying is really your choice. If you can’t find the document, that tells you how the arrangement was built.
Terms read from Angi’s pro agreement, Thumbtack’s published terms, Angi’s SEC filings and Q3 2026 investor materials, and FTC case documents; current as of November 10, 2026.


